So, where were females while males were becoming Homo sapiens?

Male egomania never ends: another scientific explanation of how the evolution of Homo sapiens was directed toward one achievement: in this case, being employed as a major league pitcher. Note how “we” means males; “all” means males. If being able to throw a fast ball at 96 mph is a significant test of being human, then there are maybe, 100 “real humans” on the planet. If you add up all “throwing sports” – a few thousand.

Someone has to give birth-perpetuate “valuable male genes” Men can’t. Fortunately for men, it’s women.

Portland flat,550x550,075,f

How Hurling Spears 2 Million Years Ago May Have Given a 96-mph Fastball

BY Rebecca Jacobson / PBS Science Wednesday 2013


When it comes to the ability to pitch a 90 mph fastball, humans are unmatched. Sure, chimpanzees can throw, but only at about 20 mph, a speed that wouldn’t land them a spot on a Little League team, said Neil Roach, a postdoctoral researcher in George Washington University’s Center for the Advanced Study of Hominid Paleobiology.

“If you look at any Little League baseball game in any town in America, you can find a 12- or 13-year-old kid that can throw 60 or 70 miles per hour on the mound at that game,” he said in a video produced by George Washington University. “And that to me is really remarkable performance. It’s what we all are capable of doing as opposed to the best athletes among us.” How do we go from a few talented-trained and practiced kids to WE ALL?

Roach and Dan Lieberman, professor of biological sciences at Harvard University, believe that early humans evolved this skill for hunting — specifically for hurling spears or rocks at small animals to kill and capture food. Their research is published in this week’s edition of the journal Nature. Backwards AGAIN: the case would have been that the environment favored individuals (pass on your genes) who could accurately throw-stun-or-kill animals; knock animals out of trees or otherwise protect a group from aggressive predators, including other humans. There is no “Big Guy in the Sky” who directs evolution toward isolated, specific goals, like throwing a fast ball. 

Our arms act like small catapults, Lieberman said in a video from Harvard University. When the pitch starts, the player twists his torso to the side, causing his arm to draw as far back as he can. That motion creates and stores the elastic energy needed to launch the ball, Lieberman said. No one is born being able to do this; why ignore training and practice and peculiar talent? 

“We’re the only creature in the world that can throw really hard and really fast at the same time,” Lieberman said — and we do it pretty accurately. When you throw, you cock your arm back, and when you do that you’re stretching, basically loading your upper arm like a catapult or a sling. And what we discovered is about half the energy you impart to a ball or a spear when you throw it comes from that elastic energy storage.” Nice physio-biology – but who is “you”?  Not females, who have a different throwing style to males. Hence the pejorative “You throw like a girl.”  

But of course: Male scientists never consider that females are intrinsic to human evolution: instead, females (if even noticed) were merely hanging around popping out (male babies) over the previous 2 million years, watching males evolve into Homo sapiens. How nice of them to let us tag along.

Throwing is the fastest motion the human body is capable of producing, Roach said, thanks to that elastic energy.

But in order to wind up for that powerful pitch, three major changes in our anatomy had to occur, the authors determined. First, we had to develop a longer torso, a product of walking upright seen in our australopithecine relatives 4 million years ago. And that torso had to be able to pivot independently of our lower body. Yes, we had to do things because evolution’s Big Guy in the Sky was planning ahead – to invent a game called baseball.

Here we see the obvious: this is MALE anatomy. (Females probably used their brains to figure out their own “food strategies” – but no; “science knows” that females sat around helpless and dependent. Second, we needed broad, flat shoulders so our arms could create a right angle, allowing our shoulders to more effectively store and release elastic energy. Try scrunching your shoulders toward your chin and throwing overhand; you’ll see why our australopithecine ancestors had a hard time. Finally, the humerus, the long bone in the upper arm, rotates where it meets the shoulder socket, something called humeral torsion. That “twist” translates to how far you can cock your arm back, Lieberman said in the video, which meant you could store more energy to impart to the ball.

And while some of these characteristics appear in early Australopithecus, all three elements appear together in Homo erectus, an ancestor that appeared about 2 million years ago, Roach said. Roach and Lieberman believe that by developing our throwing power, we were able to take down larger animals with rocks and spears — a real game-changer.

Neil Roach is looking for how humans’ throwing power explains early hunting. Photo by William Atkins/GW University Photographer Another male egomaniac!

“Hunting matters because more calories in your diet means you can build bigger bodies and bigger brains and have more babies, all of the things that matter for evolution,” Roach said. Well, thank-you for giving females something to do! (Or does he mean that hunting “improved” sperm quality?)

Rick Potts, director of the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program, doesn’t entirely agree with Roach and Lieberman’s theory. The first evidence of spears, our most powerful primitive weapons, appeared 400,000 years ago in Europe, 1.5 million years after the emergence of Homo erectus, Potts said. Homo erectus could have thrown rocks to drive away predators, he said, but the tools and skills for hunting large game didn’t appear until later. Just make up a story as you go along. Why not? It’s not like we’re doing science!

“Once you get to large animals, if you don’t hit it right where you want to every time, you just enrage the creature,” Potts said, adding that even professional pitchers miss the catcher’s glove half the time. “We don’t see points that could penetrate hide until much later in archeological records.”

Also unclear is when exactly our shoulders settled into the right position (bizarre!) to throw a weapon, said Owen Lovejoy, professor of anthropology at Kent State University, so it may not have been a primary driver in the selection process for Homo erectus. And a lot more goes into hunting than just physiology, he added.

“I wouldn’t rule out the role of the brain in a human’s ability to throw,” he said. OMG!

Roach says the team is continuing their research, searching for evidence of early projectiles to explain pre-spear hunting, and to determine how or if early humans could have taken down prey by throwing rocks or sharpened sticks.

And while modern throwing skills are largely recreational now, Roach said, understanding better how the shoulder moves and stores energy during a throw will help prevent injury for modern athletes, who sling high-speed pitches dozens of times every game. Do I smell fishing for funding by Major League Baseball?

“What happens is that people actually injure their shoulders and they injure their elbows,” Roach said. “So at the end of the day, the ability that we have to store elastic energy in our shoulder makes us great throwers, but it’s also injuring us.”

The Evolution of Our Throwing ShoulderNeil Roach, post doctoral researcher at George Washington University, explains how humans have the ability to throw with such high velocities and why this made a difference in our evolution. 
So here we are again: Backwards evolution; 1. this forces us to assume that a rock or stick can be thrown at 90+ miles an hour (I don’t think physics would bear this out. A baseball is a sphere for a reason.) 2. Male  physical structure was identical to modern fast-pitch athletes. 3. And humans over the past 2 million years ate only meat obtained by killing animals with thrown objects. 4. Oh yes – and females were not involved in evolution.

Excerpt: To understand why a girl “throws like a girl,” it’s necessary to define just what throwing like a girl is. According to Thomas, a girl throwing overhand looks more like she’s throwing a dart than a ball. It’s a slow, weak, forearm motion, with a short step on the same side as the throwing hand. A boy’s throw, by contrast, involves the entire body. Thomas describes a skillful overhand throw as an uncoiling in three phases: step (with the foot opposite the throwing hand), rotate (with hips first, then shoulders) and whip (with the arm and hand).

Girls don’t do any of those three steps as successfully as boys, but Thomas zeroes in on one aspect in particular: the rotation.

The power in an overhand throw — and in a golf swing, a tennis serve or a baseball swing — comes from the separate turning of hips and shoulders. The hips rotate forward and the body opens, and then the shoulders snap around. Women tend to rotate their hips and shoulders together, and even expert women throwers don’t get the differential that men get. “The one-piece rotation is the biggest difference,” says Thomas. “It keeps women from creating speed at the hand.” Even when women learn to rotate hips and shoulders separately, they don’t do it as fast as men.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s